Comparative study between using Lowenstein Jensen and Bio-FM media in identification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis
• 2013
معلومات البحث
المؤلفون
Sherif Ahmed Essa, Sohair Abdel-Rahman Abdel-Samea, Yasser Mahmoud Ismaeil, Ahmad Abdelsadek Mohammad
الكلمات المفتاحية
Not Available
المجلة العلمية
Not Available
الناشر
Not Available
المجلد
Not Available
العدد
Not Available
الصفحات
Not Available
publication.type
International
رابط البحث
Open Link
المواد المرفقة
Not Available
الملخص
Aim of the work: to evaluate the detection rate and time of Mycobacterium tuberculosis by using the Bio FM system in comparison with the Lowenstein-Jensen medium.
Patients and Methods:
A Total 50 smear AFB positive sputum samples were included in this study and received from three groups:
Group I:Thirty four (34) patients with fresh sputum smear + ve (New cases)
Group II:Ten (10) Relapsed cases
Group III: Six (6) Treatment failure cases all cases were exposed for Thorough history taking, Complete physical examination, routine laboratory tests including ESR, Plain chest X-ray- P.A and lateral view if needed ,Sputum smear for acid fast bacilli (Zeil Neelsen staining), Tuberculin skin test using Mantoux technique, ,Sputum culturing on Lowenstein-Jensen medium and Bio -FM medium.
Results: The shortest mean detection times on the two studied isolation media were for the cases with far advanced lesion on chest X-ray. On Lowenstein Jensen, it was (17.50 days ± 6.802) and on Bio-FM it was (10 days ± 5.752).While the longest times were for the cases of minimal lesion, On Lowenstein Jensen, it was 24 days (±11.449) and on Bio-FM it was 15 days (±10.905).The mean detection times of moderately advanced cases on Lowenstein Jensen, it was 19.57 days (±9.086) and on Bio-FM was 12.65 days (± 8.074).
Conclusion: Bio-FM showed greater superiority in detection time over Lowenstein Jensen with no significant difference between the two media in detection rate.
Patients and Methods:
A Total 50 smear AFB positive sputum samples were included in this study and received from three groups:
Group I:Thirty four (34) patients with fresh sputum smear + ve (New cases)
Group II:Ten (10) Relapsed cases
Group III: Six (6) Treatment failure cases all cases were exposed for Thorough history taking, Complete physical examination, routine laboratory tests including ESR, Plain chest X-ray- P.A and lateral view if needed ,Sputum smear for acid fast bacilli (Zeil Neelsen staining), Tuberculin skin test using Mantoux technique, ,Sputum culturing on Lowenstein-Jensen medium and Bio -FM medium.
Results: The shortest mean detection times on the two studied isolation media were for the cases with far advanced lesion on chest X-ray. On Lowenstein Jensen, it was (17.50 days ± 6.802) and on Bio-FM it was (10 days ± 5.752).While the longest times were for the cases of minimal lesion, On Lowenstein Jensen, it was 24 days (±11.449) and on Bio-FM it was 15 days (±10.905).The mean detection times of moderately advanced cases on Lowenstein Jensen, it was 19.57 days (±9.086) and on Bio-FM was 12.65 days (± 8.074).
Conclusion: Bio-FM showed greater superiority in detection time over Lowenstein Jensen with no significant difference between the two media in detection rate.
أعضاء هيئة التدريس - جامعة بنها